Commercial Litigation Developments
FBFK’s weekly look at notable developments in commercial disputes, trials, appeals, class actions and technology litigation, with an emphasis on Texas and California.
Texas voters reshaped the appeals courts that hear the state’s biggest business dispute cases. They voted out four Texas Supreme Court justices and every justice on the Fifteenth Court of Appeals. In California, the Ninth Circuit revived the jury’s antitrust verdict in the NFL Sunday Ticket case and kept a hold on state limit employer speech. Legal fights over rules for teens on social media and over the California’s first carbon capture project also moved forward in the courts. What ties these stories together is that who decides a dispute, and where, equally matter.
Democrats Win Four Texas Supreme Court Seats, Including Chief Justice, as GOP Keeps 5–4 Majority
Democrats won all four Texas Supreme Court seats at the Nov. 3 election. Maggie Ellis, a justice on the Third Court of Appeals, defeated Chief Justice Jimmy Blacklock, becoming the first woman elected chief justice of Texas. Justices James Sullivan, Kyle Hawkins and Brett Busby lost their seats to Chari Kelly, Kristen Hawkins and Gisela Triana. Five Republican-held seats weren’t on the ballot, so the GOP keeps a 5–4 majority on the nine-member court. The new justices take office Jan. 1. The takeaway: with only a one-vote majority and four new justices, close business cases may be harder to determine, from arbitration fights to large jury verdicts appeals. Companies with cases likely to reach the court should rethink their assumptions about timing and settlement.
Sources: The Texas Tribune, “Texas Democrats break Republican hold on statewide courts”; The Texas Lawbook, “In a Shocker, Democrats Sweep Top Appeals Court Elections” (Subscription required); Texas Public Radio (KERA), “The Texas Supreme Court will have a female majority for the first time”
Voters Replace All Three Fifteenth Court of Appeals Justices; Court Cancels Four December Arguments
The same election also removed every justice’s seat on the Fifteenth Court of Appeals. Texas created this statewide court in 2023 to hear civil cases involving the state, challenges to state laws and appeals from the Texas Business Court. Gov. Greg Abbott appointed all three of its justices in 2024: Chief Justice Scott Brister and Justices Scott Field and April Farris. They lost to Jerry Zimmerer, Tom Baker and Marc Meyer. Since the election, the court has canceled four high-profile cases that had been scheduled for December. Brister told The Texas Lawbook that no other court of appeals has had all of its judges replaced on a single day. The takeaway: anyone with a Business Court appeal or a state-related case pending at the Fifteenth Court should expect new panels, possible reargument and delays.
Sources: The Texas Lawbook, “‘Triage’ Mode: 15th COA Cancels Four Oral Arguments Set for December” (Subscription required); The Texas Tribune, “Texas Democrats break Republican hold on statewide courts”
NRA Seeks $200 Million-Plus From Former Outside Counsel William Brewer and His Law Firm
The National Rifle Association has asked a Dallas County district court to send its claims against William Brewer and his law firm to arbitration before JAMS. The firm served as the NRA’s counsel for more than six years. In the October filing, the NRA alleges malpractice and breaches of professional and fiduciary duties, it seeks repayment of $200 million in legal fees plus additional damages. According to the NRA, the firm was hired in March 2018 to handle a single insurance-regulatory inquiry, and that work grew into nationwide representation. The expanded work included the Ackerman McQueen litigation and a Chapter 11 case that was dismissed because it was not filed in good faith. The firm told The Texas Lawbook that the claims are baseless and it will defend its record. The takeaway: an arbitration clause in an engagement letter can move a nine-figure malpractice claim into a private forum, so review the dispute terms whenever an engagement expands.
Sources: The Texas Lawbook, “UPDATED: NRA Sues William Brewer and His Law Firm for $200 Million-Plus” (Subscription required); The Dallas Morning News, “NRA sues Dallas lawyer for nearly ‘destroying the organization’ he represented” (Subscription required); Yahoo News, “NRA sues Dallas lawyer for nearly ‘destroying the organization’ he represented”
Ninth Circuit Revives NFL Sunday Ticket Antitrust Verdict but Orders New Trial on Damages
On Oct. 30, the Ninth Circuit reversed U.S. District Judge Philip Gutierrez’s decision to throw out the jury verdict in the antitrust class action over the NFL’s Sunday Ticket package. A federal jury in Los Angeles returned the verdict in 2024, awarding $4.6 billion to residential subscribers and $96.9 million to commercial subscribers (restaurants, bars). The appeals panel held that the trial judge abused the court’s discretion by excluding testimony from the plaintiffs’ experts. The panel ordered the jury’s liability verdict reinstated but upheld the order for a new trial on damages. The NFL said it is disappointed and is considering asking for further review. The takeaway: once a jury has heard and weighed expert testimony, throwing that testimony out after trial is difficult to defend on appeal. Challenges to the other side’s experts are best won before trial.
Sources: Reuters (via Insurance Journal), “US Court Reinstates ‘Sunday Ticket’ Class Action Verdict Against NFL”; U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, “In re National Football League’s ‘Sunday Ticket’ Antitrust Litigation” (opinion)
Ninth Circuit Keeps California’s Ban on Mandatory “Captive Audience” Meetings Blocked
On Oct. 29, the Ninth Circuit upheld a preliminary injunction that blocks California from enforcing SB 399 in California Chamber of Commerce v. Bonta. The law took effect in January 2025 and bars employers from penalizing workers who skip employer-sponsored meetings about political or religious matters, including meetings about whether to join or support a union. Violations carry a $500 penalty per employee, per violation, and workers can also sue individually. The court held that the industry groups are most likely to win their First Amendment claim, because the law singles out speech based on the subject and who is speaking. The court didn’t decide whether federal labor law preempts SB 399. The takeaway: because the ruling is only preliminary, California employers can hold these meetings for now, but they shouldn’t treat the issue as resolved.
Sources: Virginia Lawyers Weekly (BridgeTower Media Newswires), “Federal appeals court blocks state law restricting mandatory workplace meetings”; U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, “California Chamber of Commerce v. Bonta” (opinion)
Related: Labor & Employment
Meta, Google and TikTok Sue California AG Rob Bonta to Block AB 1709’s Limits on Teen Feeds
Meta, Google and TikTok have each sued California Attorney General Rob Bonta in federal court, filing separately in San Francisco, Los Angeles and San Jose. They want to block AB 1709 before it takes effect on Jan. 1, 2027. Gov. Gavin Newsom signed the law in September. It bars platforms from offering personalized feeds, endless scrolling and autoplay videos to users under the age of 16. Platforms must also take reasonable steps with age verification to keep underage users away from the features. Fines can reach $50,000 for each affected user under 16. The companies argue that the law violates the First Amendment and is preempted by Section 230. Bonta’s office said it is reviewing the lawsuits. The takeaway: consumer apps that use algorithmic feeds and have younger users should be ready to comply by January instead of counting on a court to block the law.
Sources: TechCrunch, “Meta, Google, and TikTok sue California AG over teen social media law”; The Associated Press (via ABC7 News), “Google, Meta and TikTok sue California over law designed to protect children from social media harms”
Related: Intellectual Property & Technology
Kern County Judge Sets Aside Approval of California Resources’ Carbon TerraVault Project
Kern County Judge Marcos Camacho ruled that the county’s October 2024 approval of Carbon TerraVault 1 violated California state environmental law and must be set aside. The project is run by California Resources Corp. (CRC) in the Elk Hills oil field, and is the state’s first operating carbon capture and storage project. The Center for Biological Diversity along with other environmental and community groups challenged the county’s environmental review. The judge agreed with them on several points, including that the review didn’t analyze the industries expected to supply the carbon dioxide. The judgment isn’t final yet. CRC said it will pursue all available options, and the EPA said the ruling doesn’t affect CRC’s federal permits. The takeaway: federal permits don’t protect a California project from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), so California environmental reviews should cover foreseeable future plans from the beginning.
Source: CalMatters, “Court rules against California’s first carbon capture project, a key piece of state climate plans”
Related: Real Estate & Land Use
About FBFK Litigation
FBFK’s litigation and trial lawyers represent businesses in commercial disputes, trials, appeals, class actions and technology litigation. Learn more about FBFK Litigation & Trial.
This summary is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.